IGW'15: Governance in emerging markets (panel discussion)

A panel of three very capable thinkers offered conference delegates insights into boards; board practice; and, continuing tensions between calls for corporate governance reforms in emerging markets, vibrant cultural differences and inconsistent capital market pressures. a summary of the insights and comments offered by panel members Thomas Clarke (UTS, Australia), Anderson Seny Kan (Université de Toulouse, France) and David Zoogah (Morgan State University, Baltimore, USA) follow:

• Clarke observed the many emerging markets had, in fact, emerged. They have become powerful in their own right. However, varieties of capitalism exist (the BRICS economies were compared and contrasted), all of which stand in contrast to the Anglo–American model  of hard legal and regulatory structures, and market oriented corporate governance.
• Seny Kan suggested the boards are 'social spaces' and that culturally appropriate tools are required to 'govern' such spaces. The emergence of post-colonialism has seen a marked reaction against colonial forces in many cases, thus leading to some very stressed and complicated situations. A regime of practices may be required to 'normalise' practices within each economy, but not to (re)impose Anglo models that simply don't fit the cultural context particularly well.
• Zoogah took a slightly different perspective, by comment on something he called the 'natural resource curse'. The catalyst for the entry of many big firms into so-called third world emerging economies has been natural resources. this has brought employment and economic growth, however in many cases the modus operandi has been exploitation not endowment. Firms have failed to embrace the grand challenge of tidying up, or by sharing the wealth created in any equitable manner. 

While the three panel speakers observed many idiosyncrasies between emerging markets and with developed Anglo–American economies, a common thread emerged during the discussion. In most cases exogenous forces have held much of the power but this is starting to change. The role of the company in each economy is pivotal, both to the effective and fair operation of markets, and to contribute to the well-being of all citizens. 

While the panel members did not explicitly focus their comments directly on corporate governance, the linkages and implications for boards were clear: that company leaders and boards have a crucial role to play in the development of emerging economies, and that role needs to be taken seriously.